Ben Justice
Lawson
Organized Crime 1880-1920
With the growth of cities, many new things came around, new modes of transportation, new living habits, and new illegal activities. Although crime has been around since the beginning of humans, stealing the other tribes food, murder, extortion, prostitution, crime has evolved, and will continue to evolve through time. While crime wasn’t the biggest event of the time, many reports on gang activities made the front page on many large newspapers such as the New York Times.
One of the first groups to rise in New York’s new crime era was the Whyos, named due to their odd warcry, the Whyos were around from the late 1860s to the early 1880s. While they started out before 1880, they really only started gaining substantial power around 1880. Their power came many ways, extortion, prostitution, and murder were their specialties. The Whyos weren’t just some street gang either, you had to have killed at least one person to be let in. Around the late 1880s, early 1890s the Whyos were being run down, either from death or imprisonment, they were all but gone. The absolute final straw was pulled when the leaders got in an argument about money and had a drunken shootout, resulting in no casualties, only incarceration.
The rise of the Eastman Gang came around at the fall of the Whyos, but they were not the only ones to rise, the Five Points Gang was the other big Gang that came out of the Whyos elimination. The Eastman Gang dominated New York from around 1890 to 1910. Their wealth and power came from various illegal activities such as prostitution and illegal gambling. The Eastman Gang came close to an end when Monk Eastman, founder and leader of the Eastman Gang, was arrested. When Monk was released he went into the army and fought bravely in WWI and was honorably discharged. It is rumored during his physical that the doctor asked what war he had been in, seeing all the stab and gunshot wounds, Monk replied with “Just a few(wars) in New York”. Following Monk’s death the gang was split into 3 factions and was later brought down when 2 of the 3 abandoned the 3rd leader at a robbery, leaving him for the police.
The Five Points Gang was the other big gang around the turn of the century. Mortal enemies of the Eastman Gang, The Five Points Gang was more like how we think of the Mafia, many famous gangsters were in the Five Points Gang in their earlier years. Al Capone, later to be leader of the Chicago Outfit, Charles “Lucky” Luciano, said to be the most powerful criminal in American history, and many other smaller names. The Five Points Gang rose quickly to power due to their support of corrupt politicians. Eventually the Tammany Hall officials, the corrupt party at that time, stopped helping Eastman and only supported The Five Points Gang. This led to the slight rise over the Eastman Gang for the Five Pointers.
The constantly raging war between the Five Pointers and Eastmen led to many casualties, and many huge battles. One of these battles in particular consisted of over 50 members on each side fighting in the middle of New York City. This particular event happened because a Five Pointer shot Monk Eastman in the stomach, he survived, and then an Eastman killed a Five Pointer. At one point the war was so bad that officials told Paul Kelly, leader of the Five Pointers, and Monk Eastman, Eastman leader, to fight it out in a boxing match, winner takes all. This meant whoever lost forfeited everything their gang owned, to the other, no one wanted to lose this. The boxing match starts and Kelly looks much better than Eastman, Kelly was a boxer so he knows what he is doing, but Eastman is a big guy. Eventually the match had lasted over two hours and was declared a tie and the war raged on.
The were many other smaller gangs, pickpocket groups, all focused on smaller crimes.
These groups were very smart however, one method used by pickpockets was to get one
member to ride a bike into a pedestrian and start an argument, as the argument drew a
crowd the other members would pickpocket the crowd and would then go to their
headquarters to divide the money. They didn’t always do it themselves though, one boy
trained his dog to snatch purses and run them around the corner where he would be
waiting.
| Paul Kelly |
![]() |
| Monk Eastman |
![]() |
| Five Points, NYC |
| Five Points Gang |
| Monk Eastman |
The Encyclopedia of American Crime (book)
General information on types of crime and big names in the business
General information on types of crime and big names in the business
General information on crime of the era.
More racial facts that showed more about the crime wave rising with immigrants
The Gangs of New York (book)
General knowledge, but more specifically in New York
General knowledge, but more specifically in New York
The Mafia Encyclopedia (book)
Although this was more about later things, it was useful for finding the transition from gang to mafia
Although this was more about later things, it was useful for finding the transition from gang to mafia
The Apaches of New York (book)
Interesting view on literature and crime in the same
Interesting view on literature and crime in the same
Yakey Yakes Shoot Cherry Hill Gang Member (NYT Article, 1905)
A news article about a gang shooting
A news article about a gang shooting
Round-Up Gang Members (NYT Article, 1905)
A news article about stopping gangs
A news article about stopping gangs



